Do ESG Investors Care About Carbon Emissions? Evidence From Securitized Auto Loans
Working paper. First version September 2022; this draft April 2026.
Abstract
This paper documents that ESG preferences in fixed income markets affect real outcomes through securitization. I find that higher ESG scores lower funding costs for auto loan securitizations and that captive lenders pass through these savings to consumers: a 9 basis points ESG funding advantage translates into a 21 to 33 basis points lower consumer interest rate. The high pass-through is driven by an increased probability of receiving a subsidized interest rate (e.g., 0% financing). Lower consumer borrowing costs increase loan demand by up to 4.9%. Yet because issuer ESG scores are weak proxies for financed CO2 emissions, the same mechanism reduces the cost of capital for high-emission vehicles. A subjective-beliefs model can explain how investors who intend to price emissions but implement this via ESG scores lower the cost of capital of high-emission vehicles.
Winner of the 6th Annual Sustainable Finance in Fixed Income Research Competition '26 UN PRI Best PhD Paper '25 FIRS PhD Paper Prize '24 GRASFI Best PhD Paper '24 Myron Scholes PhD Prize '24 Citations: 12
In plain language
Carmakers' lending arms and other lenders fund car loans by bundling them into bonds and selling the bonds to investors. Investors accept a slightly lower return on bonds from issuers with high ESG scores. Carmakers' lending arms pass that saving on to car buyers as cheaper loans, often as 0% financing offers. But an issuer's ESG score says little about how much CO2 the financed cars emit, so the cheaper loans also reach buyers of high-emission vehicles.
Key findings
- Higher issuer ESG scores lower funding costs for auto loan securitizations: moving from the 20th to the 80th percentile of ESG scores lowers issuance spreads by 9 basis points.
- Captive lenders pass the savings on to consumers: interest rates are 21 to 33 basis points lower, with more subsidized (e.g., 0%) financing, and loan demand rises by up to 4.9%.
- Issuer ESG scores are weak proxies for financed CO2 emissions, so high-emission vehicles also get cheaper capital.
- A subjective-beliefs model explains how investors who intend to price emissions, but do so through ESG scores, end up lowering the cost of capital of high-emission vehicles.
Key figure
Cite this paper
Kontz, C. (2023). Do ESG Investors Care About Carbon Emissions? Evidence From Securitized Auto Loans. Working paper. SSRN 4357312.
Presentations and awards
- Conferences: FIRS Conference 2024, OU-RFS Climate and Energy Conference 2024, GRASFI Conference 2024, SoFiE Conference 2024, CEPR-ESSEC-Luxembourg Conference on Sustainable Financial Intermediation, Harvard Climate Economics Workshop, UC Santa Cruz
- Awards: Winner of the 6th Annual Sustainable Finance in Fixed Income Research Competition (FIASI), UN PRI Best PhD Student Paper Award 2025, FIRS Conference 2024 Prize for PhD Students, GRASFI Conference 2024 Best PhD Paper Award, Myron S. Scholes PhD Prize 2024
Questions about this paper
What does this paper find, in plain terms?
Car loans bundled by issuers with high ESG scores are cheaper to fund, and carmakers' lending arms pass those savings to buyers as lower interest rates. But ESG scores track emissions poorly, so the same discount also flows to high-emission vehicles.
What is the main finding?
Moving from the 20th to the 80th percentile of issuer ESG scores lowers the issuance spread of an auto loan securitization by 9 basis points. Captive lenders pass this on: consumer interest rates fall by 21 to 33 basis points, driven by a higher probability of a subsidized rate such as 0% financing, and loan demand rises by 1.1% to 4.9%. Because issuer ESG scores are weak proxies for financed CO2 emissions, the same mechanism lowers the cost of capital for high-emission vehicles.
What data does the paper use?
Loan-level data on 17.8 million vehicle loans that serve as collateral for all auto asset-backed securities issued from 2017 to 2022, merged with EPA CO2 emissions data at the make, model, and year level. Issuer-level ESG scores come from MSCI, Sustainalytics, Refinitiv, and S&P.
How is the effect identified?
Senior tranches of auto ABS are highly standardized and considered safe assets, so the comparison holds risk exposure constant while greenness varies. The estimates control for variables derived from loan-level data, include ex-post prepayments as placebo controls, and use fixed effects that capture security design. The pass-through to consumer interest rates is estimated with instrumental variables that isolate variation in lenders' common funding costs.
How do I cite this paper?
Kontz, C. (2023). Do ESG Investors Care About Carbon Emissions? Evidence From Securitized Auto Loans. Working paper. SSRN 4357312. A BibTeX entry is in the Cite this paper section.
Where can I get the latest draft?
The current draft (April 2026) is available as a PDF on this site and on SSRN.